🥊 Safari 扩展硬核对决

PiPifier vs Vinegar - Tube Cleaner

基于 Apple App Store 真实元数据、果粉口碑与综合健康质量分客观评测

PiPifier

PiPifier

by Arno Appenzeller

🏆 89/100 (A)★ 4.4

一键将网页中正在播放的任意视频以苹果原生画中画模式弹出。

Vinegar - Tube Cleaner

Vinegar - Tube Cleaner

by And a Dinosaur

🏆 87/100 (A)★ 4.2

将 YouTube 播放器替换为纯净流畅的原生 HTML5 播放器,干掉广告与追踪。

Price
$1.99 (one-time)
查看详情 →
⚖️ SafariExt 编辑部裁决建议

面对两款扩展,你该如何选择?

PiPifier 简单纯粹免费;Vinegar 则对 YouTube 生态进行了底层级别的彻底改造。

👉 PiPifier

选择 PiPifier:如果你只需要一个完全免费、点击一下即可让任何普通网页视频浮动置顶画中画的极简工具。

👉 Vinegar - Tube Cleaner

选择 Vinegar:如果你看 YouTube 居多,需要深度剔除贴片广告、恢复 4K 播放与后台省电播放。

硬核参数与规格对比表

对比维度PiPifierVinegar - Tube Cleaner
综合健康质量分89 (A)87 (A)
定价方式完全免费$1.99 (one-time)
安装包体积1.5 MB9.3 MB
官方评分★ 4.4 (324 条)★ 4.2 (762 条)
最低系统要求macOS 15.0+macOS 15.0+
开源状态✅ YesNo (Proprietary)
维护状态积极维护中积极维护中
⭐️ App Store 真实果粉口碑碰撞

两款扩展的真实用户体验

PiPifier

★2026-01-14
Not functional for me

"Neither the extensions nor the share method would allow me to enable pipifier! Was really hoping this would be good since i'd heard so many good things about"

— whateverjxjdjsns
★★★★★2025-12-16
So good!!

"This is absolutely PERFECT!! I can play Roblox on it, and listen to music with a tap!! I love this, now I can sing more."

— 🫶🌸Laya

Vinegar - Tube Cleaner

★★★★★2026-10-28
Makes youtube tolerable

"Vinegar has made viewing content on youtube so much better. However, the most recent update seems to have introduced a bug with audio. Videos now always open with audio muted by default. After adjusting the audio level, it will spontaneously revert to muted after some random interval while viewing content. Hopefully that issue will be addressed soon. Edited to add: Contacted developer who advised tapping the M key to either enable or mute the video audio, rather than using the in-screen volume slider. Works perfectly, and audio remains stable."

— RanchwoodRoad
★★★★★2026-10-20
Well crafted and maintained necessity

"This extension makes the web app version of YouTube actually usable. Bugs ineveitably appear as Apple, YouTube, and so forth change their architecture, but vinegar keeps up with it. I am very satisfied. My only requests would be a native integration with Sponsorblock when it is also present because it hides video scrub bar category colors, and a way to change audio tracks, if these are doable. Nevertheless, it is a phenomenal extension."

— The Gane Rater.